Current status of the Ning Platform is always available on the Ning Status Blog.

Forum

Ning 3.0 Forum Questions and Concerns

Hello,

I've just launched a sandbox site and have barely scratched the surface playing with it. I'm sure I'll have many questions and suggestions as I dig deeper into the new platform, but right now I have three questions about the forum feature.

1. The comment options are Disqus/standard/none. So just to clarify -- if Disqus comments are selected, members will not be presented with the option to comment using their network profile?

2. There doesn't appear to be a search option for the forum, which concerns me. A lot, actually.

3. Is Facebook commenting an option?

Thanks!

Kristy 

You need to be a member of Ning Creators Social Network to add comments!

Join Ning Creators Social Network

Email me when people reply –

Replies

  • Can anyone comment on reply structure? Is it threaded (like creators) or chronological (with quotes for replies to replies)?

    • Hi Chris,

      The reply structure is currently flat; a threaded reply mechanism is in place, but we're fine-tuning the experience for mobile before making it available.

      Thanks,
      Phil

      • The reply structure is currently flat; a threaded reply mechanism is in place, but we're fine-tuning the experience for mobile before making it available.

        Hey Phil, thanks for the reply. Two questions, with a bit of background:

        My forums are threaded, like here. I have been wanting to switch to flat (with quotes) but I can't as my many current discussions would lose all sense - replies would be out of order with no way of knowing how to follow a discussion.

         - does (or will) the "flat" format automatically quote whichever comment is being replied to? This is huge for maintaining readability.

         - would we be able to set this per forum? i.e. could I import my current forum in it's current threaded form, as a sort of archive, and have other new forums set to flat (with quotes)?

        • Hi Chris,

          You can set comments (native with or without HTML replies/FB/Disqus) per forum. Right now there isn't a quoting function; we've experimented with a few different ways to have a flat structure that still makes it easy to follow individual threads, but we're not there yet.

          When you import your existing network content, it will be a single forum instance, so you'd be able to nominate that as an archive (and very likely keep the current threading model) and start a new forum or forums and have a different commenting model for them.

          Thanks,
          Phil

          • Fabulous, thanks Phil!

          • Hi Phil,

            Facebook and Network commenting for blogs will not be combined? 

            • Hi Rowald,

              No, you can choose network comments or facebook comments per blog/forum/photo section; you can't combine them in one. We thought about that but decided that the interaction would be too confusing.

              Thanks,
              Phil

              • Although I really hoped this would be possible somehow I can imagine this will be confusing to some.

  • Hi Kristy,

    Yes, FB comments are an option. You'll need to set up a FB app under the Facebook Integration admin page to enable it.

    Facebook and Disqus comments are there as options, and if you selected those, members would need to use that system, rather than their network profile, to comment. They are there as options so that you can have mixed privacy modes throughout your network on a per page basis. You might have internal members-only blogs and forums that require membership to comment, and public blogs and forums where non-members can easily contribute. 

    Search is coming.

    Thanks,
    Phil

  • Why, in the forum, some people see the complete text editor and others not? Look at this.

This reply was deleted.

Search the Creators Network

Latest Activity

Ceddy J replied to Kyryl_Ning_Support's discussion Chat Feature Update on Ning 3.0 is ready!
"So it just dawned on me that you're a CSS Maestro! Impressed by your chops."
1 hour ago
Kyryl_Ning_Support replied to Kyryl_Ning_Support's discussion Chat Feature Update on Ning 3.0 is ready!
"Hi there!
Here is what I have been able to do. all the following code sould be put in custom CSS fi…"
2 hours ago
Ning via Facebook

#Ning #search #news The long-awaited Search Option on Ning 3.0 is here! We are happy to…

Kos replied to Kyryl_Ning_Support's discussion The long-awaited Search Option is now at your fingertips!
"We've been waiting for years................Thank you (new) Ning!  Keep those improvements coming. "
3 hours ago
Kos replied to Kyryl_Ning_Support's discussion Chat Feature Update on Ning 3.0 is ready!
"YAYYYYY!  It's back!  The small chat in the corner is entirely too small for us - nothing is better…"
3 hours ago
Kyryl_Ning_Support replied to Kyryl_Ning_Support's discussion Chat Feature Update on Ning 3.0 is ready!
"IMPORTANT UPDATE!
If you are using the domain mapping it's necessary to use the custom domain name…"
3 hours ago
Kyryl_Ning_Support replied to Kyryl_Ning_Support's discussion Chat Feature Update on Ning 3.0 is ready!
"Hi Kos!
Regarding the Url to embed. Please check the third page with comments under this post. I ha…"
3 hours ago
Ceddy J replied to Kyryl_Ning_Support's discussion Chat Feature Update on Ning 3.0 is ready!
"Oh yes I love it the bubble! I live my life in a bubble lol."
3 hours ago
Kos replied to Kyryl_Ning_Support's discussion Chat Feature Update on Ning 3.0 is ready!
"Kyryl you must be the magic charm because low and behold......the sound began working today.  *lol*…"
3 hours ago
Ceddy J replied to Kyryl_Ning_Support's discussion The long-awaited Search Option is now at your fingertips!
"One recommendation is the advanced search filter like 2.0. This will allow for a great compliment t…"
4 hours ago
Jords replied to Kyryl_Ning_Support's discussion Paid Access demo version
"Thanks for passing this on Kyryl. :)"
4 hours ago
Kyryl_Ning_Support replied to Kyryl_Ning_Support's discussion Free Groups and Events Features for Ning 2.0 Mini plan!
"Hi Thiago,
I see that you have posted this suggestion everywhere you've been able to :-)
No worries…"
4 hours ago
Jords replied to Kyryl_Ning_Support's discussion The long-awaited Search Option is now at your fingertips!
"Excellent! To bad it's not July, because with these updates, it feels like Christmas!"
4 hours ago
Kyryl_Ning_Support replied to Kyryl_Ning_Support's discussion Paid Access demo version
"Hi there!
The paid access will be granting the access to the certain content for the paid members,…"
4 hours ago
Kyryl_Ning_Support replied to Kyryl_Ning_Support's discussion Paid Access demo version
"Hi Dan,
I'm sorry to say this but we already have necessary amount of beta testers :-(
But anyway t…"
4 hours ago
Kyryl_Ning_Support replied to Yana Ning Support's discussion Product Plan Update
"Hi there!
We have just run the test and chat seems to be working fine. Please try clear cache and c…"
4 hours ago
Kyryl_Ning_Support replied to Yana Ning Support's discussion Product Plan Update
"Hi there!
I have posted your suggestion to change the layout of the chat and left the same function…"
4 hours ago
Paul Corona replied to Dr. Krishna Kumari Challa's discussion I am unable to find discussions on my network when I search. Any solutions?
"I have this code on our main page as a search function that works well:
<form target="_new" action=…"
4 hours ago
Writer Chick {Diane} replied to Kyryl_Ning_Support's discussion Chat Feature Update on Ning 3.0 is ready!
"Okay, thanks for responding! "
5 hours ago
Kyryl_Ning_Support replied to Yana Ning Support's discussion Product Plan Update
"HI there!
Thanks for your nice words! Couid you please attach the screenshot how the serach looks o…"
5 hours ago
More…