Current status of the Ning Platform is always available on the Ning Status Blog.

Forum

Guys,

I post this question in another similar topic. But since I haven't receive any reply, I am trying again here. Sorry to repeat.

PLEASE NING ADMINS!!!

We need a solution for those spammer bots who create stupid e-mails like the title I wrote above.

I have two networks, even the one which is in portuguese, is having the same problem. 

Everyday I have to suspend between 5 and 10 of this bots. Everyday! I use e-mail confirmation and captcha.

The problem is that they post content and my networks become ugly and nonsense, with a lot of christmas, medicine, haircuts, whatever offers. But we talk about technology!

PLEASE NING TEAM. HELP HERE!!!

You need to be a member of Ning Creators Network to add comments!

Join Ning Creators Network

Email me when people reply –

Replies

  • NC for Hire

    easy solution:  Turn on the feature that makes them confirm their email address.  Then change your sign-up quiz to something only your 'type' of members would know.  Got rid of mine in a snap

  • Hey, Marcelo. Your title for this discussion is wonderful. Well played. 

    Sorry if we haven't been able to respond to you on this issue. We can't always respond to everyone, but I'll give it my best shot here as I have in other spots. 

    I think that JFarrow's Sign-up Quiz suggestion is a good one, but I know that this is a frustration for people who want to make it easier for legitimate people to sign up. The recent tools we released aren't going to help with GMail addresses, since you can't ban all GMail addresses. Unfortunately, I don't have a good answer for you. Some people have suggested a few things we could do:

    • Deny addresses with a certain number of dots in the email address, but as you can see here, this can lock out legitimate people as well. 
    • One person insisted we could pick up the phone and call Google and the issue could be solved. 
    • Some people think we should have a database of blacklisted email addresses. However, this could be problematic because it would inevitably ban legitimate people. 

    Spam is a difficult issue, to be sure. I guess the best advice I can give is to use as many of these tools we've created as you can. And, turn on member moderation. I moderate this community and see spambots from time to time, but so far my vigilance has paid off. We've never really had spam in this community because we moderate membership. 

    • NC for Hire

      yes and they watch this forum so anything we suggest publically.will be accounted for in their plan...  

      maybe you could compare the followers of this discussion ip addresses to those who comment...

  • That's bad. I hope Ning can come up with something more effective.

    Until then, I think I will try the quiz. Captcha and e-mail confirmation are not enough here.

    I saw that we can ban IP adresses and domains. But this I think won't help because they can change  all the time.

    Thank you guys for the replies and ideas!

  • I'm deleting about 7 new spammers per day. I also use captcha and email confirmation. The new tool for ban IP address and domains can't be applied, they are all @gmail and IP addresses from many places.

    It's an interesting idea to use the quiz but I din't want to add another question to new users. I understand the difficulties Eric explained, but before I define a new question with a quiz, I'd like to know if development is researching any method to reduce spammers registering, for example a tool similar to captcha but that works.

    Thanks.

    • We are not working on our own version of CAPTCHA. I think a quiz can actually be a great way to promote exclusivity. But, I can understand that you want to keep the sign-up problem as light as possible. 

  • Guys,

    The quiz is the best solution we tested here. The new member have more work to do during registration but we have less spammers now.

    Try a quick and simple question that only a human could answer correctly.

    Good look!

This reply was deleted.

Search the Creators Network

Latest Activity

Chazz replied to The Ning Team's discussion Exciting News About Ning + Cyndx LLC
"Thank you Fire-Tech! I don't understand why I didn't Pick it up like I did everything else. This sh…"
1 hour ago
Fire-Tech replied to The Ning Team's discussion Exciting News About Ning + Cyndx LLC
"Find PHP classes you like here. Add to wishlist. Wait for them to go on sale for $10 if you don't w…"
1 hour ago
Suki Winthrop replied to The Ning Team's discussion Exciting News About Ning + Cyndx LLC
"Roxanne not sure what exactly you r asking to george, but- if you have a ning 2 site you can use th…"
2 hours ago
Donna Mac replied to The Ning Team's discussion Exciting News About Ning + Cyndx LLC
"I totally love Spruz...however....the only thing that I am bugged about is there is no way to send…"
2 hours ago
Chazz replied to The Ning Team's discussion Exciting News About Ning + Cyndx LLC
"I would like to be able to learn PHP.. I can't afford to take classes to learn it. What would be a…"
2 hours ago
Chazz replied to The Ning Team's discussion Exciting News About Ning + Cyndx LLC
"I have been exploring Spruz, Fingers now crossed, I haven't had any spammers yet. When I explored D…"
2 hours ago
Chazz replied to The Ning Team's discussion Exciting News About Ning + Cyndx LLC
"I have actually had responses. Thankfully. Usually it took several days for the site to become acce…"
2 hours ago
Chad Burt replied to The Ning Team's discussion Exciting News About Ning + Cyndx LLC
"Quick thought...look at this tracert from one of my many users that have had problems for weeks:
Tr…"
3 hours ago
Roxanne Furlong replied to The Ning Team's discussion Exciting News About Ning + Cyndx LLC
"George, Can you explain this in layman (or doesn't know crap) terms? I have no idea how or what to…"
3 hours ago
Suzie Nielsen replied to The Ning Team's discussion Exciting News About Ning + Cyndx LLC
"Yeah, I guess it is not the answer... now I hear folks are checking with their servers..."
3 hours ago
Shadow replied to The Ning Team's discussion Exciting News About Ning + Cyndx LLC
"Thank you and yes. dealing with such diversity age or mindset is hard to please all.. but mind that…"
3 hours ago
Donna Mac replied to The Ning Team's discussion Exciting News About Ning + Cyndx LLC
"My site is private by approval only so I guess that would not apply.  I also don't have the name Sp…"
4 hours ago
Shadow replied to The Ning Team's discussion Exciting News About Ning + Cyndx LLC
"Have you noticed a bunch of spamming in Spruz.. I had asked one here about Spruz as it was suggeste…"
4 hours ago
Donna Mac replied to The Ning Team's discussion Exciting News About Ning + Cyndx LLC
"I checked the isitdownrightnow.com and my site was indeed down.  I could not get to it from any pho…"
4 hours ago
Asil replied to The Ning Team's discussion Exciting News About Ning + Cyndx LLC
"@Donna Mac.  I suspect the issue was with your Internet Service Provider (ISP).  I was on the phone…"
4 hours ago
Suki Winthrop replied to The Ning Team's discussion Exciting News About Ning + Cyndx LLC
"Donna that sounds like Sruz is the perfect fit foryou then- so happy you will be ok! :)"
5 hours ago
Donna Mac replied to The Ning Team's discussion Exciting News About Ning + Cyndx LLC
"I totally agree.  The work I did with SE PHP was labor intensive and a learning experience that I d…"
6 hours ago
Suki Winthrop replied to The Ning Team's discussion Exciting News About Ning + Cyndx LLC
"Hey Donna, i think your last sentence says it all.  We look for something 'as good as ning'- but ni…"
6 hours ago
Donna Mac replied to The Ning Team's discussion Exciting News About Ning + Cyndx LLC
"Social Engine PHP has all the info AND Spruz has the membership profiles.  SE is offline.  WAY TOO…"
6 hours ago
Donna Mac replied to The Ning Team's discussion Exciting News About Ning + Cyndx LLC
"I have all of my content on SocialEngine PHP but it is offline.  I have member profiles and member…"
7 hours ago
More…