Current status of the Ning Platform is always available on the Ning Status Blog.

FORUM

Public vs. Private Ning Sites?

Hi everyone,

I'd like to hear your thoughts on Public vs. Private Ning sites. If switching from Private to Public, is there an easy way to lock-down all member profiles automatically so they are not searchable by Google? Or does each person have to change those settings on their own?

What do you see as advantages and disadvantages to both?

The ones I see are:

PRIVATE

  • Faster membership growth (since people need to join to see any content)
  • Relative privacy - profiles, blogs, etc not indexed by Google.


PUBLIC:

  • Easier to share and link to network content
  • Higher on search engine results
  • Slower membership growth
  • Fewer frustrated users (no longer have to sign in to see content)
  • All content automatically public and indexed by Google (I believe unless members lock them down...and I think they can make blogs/photos/videos/events private & profile page private with the exception of name and photo?)


Anything I'm missing? Other thoughts?

You need to be a member of Ning Creators Social Network to add comments!

Join Ning Creators Social Network

Email me when people reply –

Replies

  • NC for Hire
    One thing I welcome and it has already been discussed before is increased flexibility with what can be public on a private site besides the front page.

    Right now if you go to the tab manager to create a page you have options on visibility including "everyone" which is misleading. "Everyone" in this case "means everyone who is a member" It's as if when designing this it wasn't taken into account that this should have been adjusted for Private sites.

    Anyway, if I could make a page truly visible to everyone on a private network I may start to gain some of the benefits of a public network. It is a Page! It is not a forum or a blog post that includes profile info. Heck, if that is too integrated what about Notes?

    What I love about Public front page/Private Sites is the ability to have my feeds be public nonetheless. If you check out my profile you'll see I have and RSS Feed to my private blog posts on my private network on a public profile of a public site. I just love that. Most of my sites are private. I think I am just starting to get used to the public paradigm so maybe others can comment on that.
  • It seems like you've thought of all pros/cons for both:) I personally prefer having completely open sites, unless there in issue with confidentiality, such as you might find with a network for people with depression, who've had a miscarriage, or other "sensitive" topics. Perhaps if you were a business and worried about people stealing your content, or a private business/group in real-life who didn't WANT members other than your real-life members, then you might want privacy/member moderation.
This reply was deleted.

Featured Discussions

Announcements

 

Some interesting articles related to community management, digital marketing etc. could be found in our digest. Don't hesitate to leave a feedback so we would know that we should continue :-)

Latest Activity

Ana Massien replied to Ana Massien's discussion
Some recent suggestions for ning 3.0
"Yeah, well just some thoughts I have had."
2 hours ago
Garfield Archivist replied to ⚡JFarrow⌁'s discussion
2 Secret Things I learned today about Ning Communities
"Nice!"
3 hours ago
DYLAN GOODWIN updated their profile
18 hours ago
DYLAN GOODWIN replied to Scott Bishop's discussion
Photo Slideshow Not Rendering Correctly
"Speaking of slideshows -- isn't it time for more options on the sizing to eliminate the un-attracti…"
18 hours ago
This Is bully replied to Ana Massien's discussion
Some recent suggestions for ning 3.0
"Ha good luck it’s been over 8 months no new updates only promises "
20 hours ago
Claire Thomas and Ralph Stokes joined Ning Creators Social Network
21 hours ago
Ana Massien commented on Steve C's blog post To Ning's CEO
"Isn't that kind of rude to ask for the ceo stuff right out right? Most people surf with protected p…"
yesterday
Ana Massien replied to Anastasia_Ning_Support's discussion
Welcome Landing Page Builder
"I do not like the landing page thing. Doesn't flow with the rest of my theme, of course if you have…"
yesterday
Ana Massien updated their profile
yesterday
Ana Massien updated their profile photo
yesterday
Ana Massien posted a discussion
 1. On the front page, instead of going into the admin function to edit the boxes, could there poss…
yesterday
Anastasia_Ning_Support posted a discussion
Hi NING Creators! 

Due to the scheduled PayPal maintenance, today you may experience certain diffi…
yesterday
More…

Meanwhile, you can check our social media channels